By the end of season six, Gabrielle was clearly an exceptional fighter, and without question, nearly Xena's equal; however, did Gabrielle ever surpass Xena? In other words, could Gabrielle beat Xena in a fight, no matter what method of combat.
Could Post FIN Gabrielle beat Xena in a fight?
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 freakgirl32001 |
Could Post FIN Gabrielle beat Xena in a fight? |
Lead | |
|
Posts: 391 (02/04/08 01:57 AM) TX Member |
|
||
|
xenaandgab4eva |
Re: Could Post FIN Gabrielle beat Xena in a fight? | ||
|
TX Member
Posts: 2358 (02/06/08 01:46 PM) |
No way! Gabrielle did become an amazing fighter, but no one beats Xena.
|
||
|
SkyPie8748 |
Re: Could Post FIN Gabrielle beat Xena in a fight? | ||
|
TX Member
Posts: 629 (02/08/08 11:38 PM) TX Member |
As much as I'm a Gabrielle fan, I admit that I don't think that she could theoretically beat Xena in a fight. But I voted that she would come close, as Xena essentially trained her and she probably learned most of her fighting abilities from observing Xena.
|
||
|
Batrochides |
Re: Could Post FIN Gabrielle beat Xena in a fight? | ||
|
TX Member
Posts: 10709 (02/18/08 11:18 PM) |
No.
It would violate the natural laws of the Xenaverse. |
||
 twinkletoes87 |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 519 (02/24/08 10:05 AM) TX Member |
|
||
|
Priestess Charis |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 298 (02/24/08 08:53 PM)
|
Hells NO! I love Gabrielle, but no way could she have actually taken Xena. At least not taken her THAT way! Heh heh...
 xX
Charis.xX ~ The
Archives ~ Deus Diligo Mihi
|
||
|
inkypuff |
|||
|
TX New Member
Posts: 10 (02/26/08 02:01 AM) |
I would say it would be terribly close! Gabrielle knows all of Xenas "moves" and weaknesses having been trained by her for so many years. In saying
that, Xena is Xena and her power to adapt in a fight is partially what makes her so amazing
.:.
P U F F .:.
.evenindeath.
|
||
|
Jazzy WP |
|||
|
TX New Member
Posts: 70 (02/26/08 03:38 AM) |
NOPE! enough said lol
|
||
|
xenawp7706 |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 3304 (02/26/08 04:35 AM) |
No, I don't think so
 
No Xena, No Xenaverse
|
||
|
Ana Tinoco |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 186 (02/27/08 02:44 PM) |
Oh no, no way!
|
||
|
smutterly1 |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 4 (02/27/08 04:10 PM)
|
Much as I ADORE Gabrielle, Xena was just 'supernatural' in any combat situation...so I think it would have been close, but Xena'd win.
Without Gabrielle there would be NO Xena   
Thanks to SaraXenite for my wonderful ROCtemple sig Shenanigen for my lovely PLA Scroll and Dr Janice Covington for my beautiful Keeper |
||
|
sunnyskyz |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 173 (02/28/08 01:08 AM) TX Member |
Xena would beat Gabrielle she is a better fighter.
|
||
|
Xenasgrrl |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 333 (03/03/08 03:12 PM) |
I think she could come close...but only because Xena "let her get that close."
|
||
|
TwoDudes |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 557 (03/09/08 02:29 PM) |
Hell no way!! What were you smoking ..?Not even in her dreams..
 |
||
|
MiMiDaVaMpIrEpRiNcEsS |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 404 (03/10/08 07:16 AM) |
I think at the end it would be a close fight... But I think Xena would win
But if in Xena verse there is someone able to beat Xena it is Gabrielle.
|
||
|
LawLess |
Re: Could Post FIN Gabrielle beat Xena in a fight? | ||
|
TX Member
Posts: 657 (03/23/08 03:31 PM) |
Definitely, no.
LawLess |
||
|
LovingRen |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 233 (03/23/08 05:13 PM) |
Hell no!
Gabs was too small and never really an "in the zone fighter" in my mind. Xena beat and killed Gods for crying out loud so I think if there was a fight between Xena and reality then reality would get knocked out! Gabs was the lover, Xena was the fighter. Yin and Yang, chalk and cheese. |
||
|
Janna23 |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 346 (04/02/08 01:16 PM) |
Absolutely not. She can definitely hold her own, but no, couldn't defeat Xena.
|
||
|
mihb |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 755 (04/03/08 08:16 PM) |
Xena was only defeated in a fight when she allowed herself to (with the rarest exceptions). I think Xena would win but they would have a fabulous time battling
it out and it would end in a different kind of entangle.
Thanks to SaraXenite for the ROCTemple banner and JCovington for the keepership. Proud member of the PLA |
||
|
xenawp7706 |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 3722 (04/04/08 07:04 AM) |
Gabrielle was very strong at the end of FIN, but Xena was more experienced in battle
No Xena, No Xenaverse
|
||
|
Tai Warrior |
|||
|
TX Member
Posts: 9525 (04/25/08 04:20 PM) |
Not a chance in Tartarus.
Gabrielle got good by the time FIN came around...but she didn't get that good.
|
||
was an amazing fighter yes but
learnt her skills over years and lets face it she had
many 
toejam - MHoIR 
- Announcements
- Help
- Tips and Terms
- General Xena Chat
- Convention News
- Polls
- ROC Chat
- Lucy Chat
- Subtext Central
- Shipper Heaven
- Fencesitters Forum
- Herc Chat
- TV, Movies, Music, Games
- Readers Review
- Sci-Fi Central
- Sports Center
- Nutbread Cafe
- Fight Club
- Adults Only
- Current events
- Complaint Forum
- TX Archives Jan. 2001 - May, 2005
- General Xena Chat Archive I
- General Xena Chat Archive II
- General Xena Chat Archive III
- General Xena Chat Archives IV
- General Xena Chat Archives V
- General Xena Chat Archives VI
- General Xena Chat Archives VII
- General Xena Chat Archives VIII
- General Xena Chat Archives IX
- Lucy Chat Archives I
- Lucy Chat Archives II
- ROC Chat Archives I
- Subtext Central Archive 1
- Fight Club Archive
- Hercules Archives 1
